Saturday, September 27, 2025

New Thoughts on Keeping Superannuation in Accumulation Mode

A year ago, I wrote a post about whether you should initially keep your superannuation in accumulation mode when you retire. I thought that if you don't need to spend the money in your superannuation accounts right away, it doesn't make sense to pay out that money to sit in regular taxed investments. But I missed one key point. Dividends from what Americans call "taxable accounts" are taxable whether you spend them or not, but capital gains are only taxed if you sell. The more capital gains you realise, the higher tax bracket you are going to be in. Unless you are lucky enough to be able to live on dividends from the "taxable accounts" alone, you are going to have to realise capital gains if you don't have a superannuation pension. 

In my case, I might be able to stay in the 16% tax bracket if I don't need to realize capital gains. So, with tax free superannuation, I will pay very little tax. If I kept my superannuation in accumulation mode, I would be paying an average of 12.5% tax on earnings in superannuation and I would have to realise $80k of capital gains in "taxable accounts" instead of receiving a superannuation pension. That would push a lot of my earnings into the 30% tax bracket.* So, I am planning to put my superannuation accounts into tax-free pension mode and pay out the minimum distribution of 4% a year until I am 65.

With my wife still earning around $45k a year in salary for now, I might not need to do much in the way of realising capital gains outside superannuation.

What about just spending the redundancy payment for the first couple of years? Some of that is going to go into superannuation and the rest will sit in our offset account. The more we spend it, the more mortgage interest we are going to have to pay. Despite that, it might actually make sense to spend that first, but psychologically I prefer a big cash buffer, low mortgage interest, and a steady pension coming in. I can just set and forget the pension from Unisuper.

* Of course, long-term capital gains are only taxed at half the headline tax rate, so the effective marginal rate would be 16% including the Medicare levy.  

No comments: